When you purchase through affiliate text and image links on Seeking Tech, we may earn a commission.

HP 934 vs. HP 934XL and HP 935 vs. HP 935XL

Both the HP 934 and HP 935 are available in normal and high yield variants. So, what are the main differences between these replacement cartridges?

You can find out in this comparison guide for the HP 934 and HP 935.

Quick Summary

With the HP 934XL High Yield Black Original Ink Cartridge, you can get around 2 ½ times more printed pages when compared to the HP 934 Black Original Ink Cartridge.

The high yield versions of the cyan, magenta and yellow cartridges can print approximately more than twice the number of pages than the normal versions.

So, although the high yield versions are more expensive, these XL cartridges also provide better value than the normal versions as you will be able to print at least 2 times as many pages.

If you are interested, you can purchase any of the aforementioned products with the following Amazon links:

HP 934 vs. HP 934XL and HP 935 vs. HP 935XL Comparison Charts

You can check out the HP 934 and HP 935 comparison tables below.

HP 934 Black vs. HP 934XL High Yield Black

 HP 934 Black Original Ink Cartridge (C2P19AN)HP 934XL High Yield Black Original Ink Cartridge (C2P23AN)
Compatible PrintersHP Officejet 6812

HP Officejet 6815

HP Officejet Pro 6230

HP Officejet Pro 6830

HP Officejet Pro 6835
HP Officejet 6812

HP Officejet 6815

HP Officejet Pro 6230

HP Officejet Pro 6830

HP Officejet Pro 6835
Ink TypePigmentPigment
Ink Drop11.77 pl11.77 pl
Page YieldAround 400 pagesAround 1000 pages
Operating Temperature Range59°F to 95°F59°F to 95°F
Storage Temperature Range32°F to 113°F32°F to 113°F
Operating Humidity Range5% to 80% RH5% to 80% RH
Storage Humidity Range5% to 80% RH5% to 80% RH
PricingCheck price on Amazon.Check price on Amazon.

HP 935 Cyan vs. HP 935XL High Yield Cyan

 HP 935 Cyan Original Ink Cartridge (C2P20AN)HP 935XL High Yield Cyan Original Ink Cartridge (C2P24AN)
Compatible PrintersHP Officejet 6812

HP Officejet 6815

HP Officejet Pro 6230

HP Officejet Pro 6830

HP Officejet Pro 6835
HP Officejet 6812

HP Officejet 6815

HP Officejet Pro 6230

HP Officejet Pro 6830

HP Officejet Pro 6835
Ink TypePigmentPigment
Ink Drop8.25 pl8.25 pl
Page YieldAround 400 pagesAround 825 pages
Operating Temperature Range59°F to 95°F59°F to 95°F
Storage Temperature Range32°F to 113°F32°F to 113°F
Operating Humidity Range5% to 80% RH5% to 80% RH
Storage Humidity Range5% to 80% RH5% to 80% RH
PricingCheck price on Amazon.Check price on Amazon.

HP 935 Magenta vs. HP 935XL High Yield Magenta

 HP 935 Magenta Original Ink Cartridge (C2P21AN)HP 935XL High Yield Magenta Original Ink Cartridge (C2P25AN)
Compatible PrintersHP Officejet 6812

HP Officejet 6815

HP Officejet Pro 6230

HP Officejet Pro 6830

HP Officejet Pro 6835
HP Officejet 6812

HP Officejet 6815

HP Officejet Pro 6230

HP Officejet Pro 6830

HP Officejet Pro 6835
Ink TypePigmentPigment
Ink Drop8.25 pl8.25 pl
Page YieldAround 400 pagesAround 825 pages
Operating Temperature Range59°F to 95°F59°F to 95°F
Storage Temperature Range32°F to 113°F32°F to 113°F
Operating Humidity Range5% to 80% RH5% to 80% RH
Storage Humidity Range5% to 80% RH5% to 80% RH
PricingCheck price on Amazon.Check price on Amazon.

HP 935 Yellow vs. HP 935XL High Yield Yellow

 HP 935 Magenta Original Ink Cartridge (C2P21AN)HP 935XL High Yield Magenta Original Ink Cartridge (C2P25AN)
Compatible PrintersHP Officejet 6812

HP Officejet 6815

HP Officejet Pro 6230

HP Officejet Pro 6830

HP Officejet Pro 6835
HP Officejet 6812

HP Officejet 6815

HP Officejet Pro 6230

HP Officejet Pro 6830

HP Officejet Pro 6835
Ink TypePigmentPigment
Ink Drop8.25 pl8.25 pl
Page YieldAround 400 pagesAround 825 pages
Operating Temperature Range59°F to 95°F59°F to 95°F
Storage Temperature Range32°F to 113°F32°F to 113°F
Operating Humidity Range5% to 80% RH5% to 80% RH
Storage Humidity Range5% to 80% RH5% to 80% RH
PricingCheck price on Amazon.Check price on Amazon.

Compatible Printers

The HP 934 Black, HP 934XL High Yield Black, HP 935 Cyan, HP 935XL High Yield Cyan, HP 935 Magenta, HP 935XL High Yield Magenta, HP 935 Yellow and HP 935XL High Yield Yellow are compatible with the following printers:

  • HP Officejet 6812
  • HP Officejet 6815
  • HP Officejet Pro 6230
  • HP Officejet Pro 6830
  • HP Officejet Pro 6835

Ink Type

The color cartridges for both variants of the HP 934 and HP 935 use the pigment ink type.

Ink Drop

The HP 934 and HP 934XL have the same ink drop. Moreover, the various color versions of the HP 935 and HP 935XL have the same ink drop as well.

You can find the ink drop specifications for these cartridges below:

  • HP 934 Black: 11.77 pl
  • HP 934XL High Yield Black: 11.77 pl
  • HP 935 Cyan: 8.25 pl
  • HP 935XL High Yield Cyan: 8.25 pl
  • HP 935 Magenta: 8.25 pl
  • HP 935XL High Yield Magenta: 8.25 pl
  • HP 935 Yellow: 8.25 pl
  • HP 935XL High Yield Yellow: 8.25 pl

Page Yield

The high yield versions of the HP934 and HP935 are able to print a lot more paper when compared to the normal versions.

With the HP 934XL High Yield Black, you will be able to print approximately 600 more pages when compared to the HP 934XL High Yield Black. So, the high yield version has a 150% advantage.

You can also print around 425 more pages with the HP 935XL High Yield Cyan than the HP 935 Cyan.

Furthermore, the HP 935XL High Yield Magenta can produce approximately 425 more pages than the HP 935 Magenta.

Finally, the HP 935XL Yellow should be able to produce around 425 more pages than the HP 935 Yellow.

Thus, the high yield versions of the HP 935 have a 106.25% advantage when compared to the normal versions.

You can check out the page yield for each of the cartridges below:

  • HP 934 Black: Around 400 pages
  • HP 934XL High Yield Black: Around 1000 pages
  • HP 935 Cyan: Around 400 pages
  • HP 935XL High Yield Cyan: Around 825 pages
  • HP 935 Magenta: Around 400 pages
  • HP 935XL High Yield Magenta: Around 825 pages
  • HP 935 Yellow: Around 400 pages
  • HP 935XL High Yield Yellow: Around 825 pages

The cartridges were tested internally by HP using the HP Officejet Pro 6830.

Operating Temperature Range

The HP 934 Black, HP 934XL High Yield Black, HP 935 Cyan, HP 935XL High Yield Cyan, HP 935 Magenta, HP 935XL High Yield Magenta, HP 935 Yellow and HP 935XL High Yield Yellow cartridges have an operating temperature range of 59°F to 95°F.

Storage Temperature Range

The HP 934, HP 934XL and HP 935 and HP 935XL also have the same storage temperature of 32°F to 113°F.

Operating Humidity Range

For humidity, these printer cartridges need to be operated at 5% to 80% RH.

Storage Humidity Range

You need to also store these products at a humidity range of 5% to 80% RH.

Resources: