When you purchase through affiliate text and image links on Seeking Tech, we may earn a commission.

HP 910 vs. HP 910XL

The HP 910 has two options as you can pick between the standard version or the XL versions. So, what are the main differences between these products?

You can find out in this comparison guide for the HP ink cartridges.

Quick Summary

You will be able to print around 175% more pages with the HP 910XL High Yield Black Original Ink Cartridge than the HP 910 Black Original Ink Cartridge.

For the non-black variants, you will be able to print approximately 161.91% more pages with the HP 910XL High Yield Cyan Original Ink Cartridge, HP 910XL High Yield Magenta Original Ink Cartridge and HP 910XL High Yield Yellow Original Ink Cartridge than the HP 910 Cyan Original Ink Cartridge, HP 910 Magenta Original Ink Cartridge and HP 910 Yellow Original Ink Cartridge.

So, even though the XL versions are more expensive, the high yield cartridges are worth the price as they will last at least 2 ½ times longer than the standard versions.

If you are interested, you can purchase any of the aforementioned HP910 ink cartridges on Amazon with the flowing links:

Comparison Charts

You can find the comparison tables for the HP910 below.

HP 910 Black vs. HP 910XL High Yield Black

 HP 910 Black Original Ink Cartridge (3YL61AN)HP 910XL High Yield Black Original Ink Cartridge (3YL65AN)
Compatible PrintersHP OfficeJet 8010 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8020 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8022 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8025 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8028 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8035 All-in-One Printer
HP OfficeJet 8010 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8020 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8022 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8025 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8028 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8035 All-in-One Printer
Ink TypePigmentPigment
Page YieldAround 300 pagesAround 825 pages
Operating Temperature Range59°F to 95°F59°F to 95°F
Storage Temperature Range-40°F to 140°F-40°F to 140°F
Operating Humidity Range20% to 80% RH20% to 80% RH
Storage Humidity Range10% to 90% RH10% to 90% RH
PricingCheck price on Amazon.Check price on Amazon.

HP 910 Cyan vs. HP 910XL High Yield Cyan

 HP 910 Cyan Original Ink Cartridge (3YL58AN)HP 910XL High Yield Cyan Original Ink Cartridge (3YL62AN)
Compatible PrintersHP OfficeJet 8010 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8020 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8022 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8025 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8028 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8035 All-in-One Printer
HP OfficeJet 8010 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8020 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8022 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8025 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8028 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8035 All-in-One Printer
Ink TypePigmentPigment
Page YieldAround 315 pagesAround 825 pages
Operating Temperature Range59°F to 95°F59°F to 95°F
Storage Temperature Range-40°F to 140°F-40°F to 140°F
Operating Humidity Range20% to 80% RH20% to 80% RH
Storage Humidity Range10% to 90% RH10% to 90% RH
PricingCheck price on Amazon.Check price on Amazon.

HP 910 Magenta vs. HP 910XL High Yield Magenta

 HP 910 Magenta Original Ink Cartridge (3YL59AN)HP 910XL High Yield Magenta Original Ink Cartridge (3YL63AN)
Compatible PrintersHP OfficeJet 8010 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8020 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8022 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8025 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8028 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8035 All-in-One Printer
HP OfficeJet 8010 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8020 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8022 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8025 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8028 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8035 All-in-One Printer
Ink TypePigmentPigment
Page YieldAround 315 pagesAround 825 pages
Operating Temperature Range59°F to 95°F59°F to 95°F
Storage Temperature Range-40°F to 140°F-40°F to 140°F
Operating Humidity Range20% to 80% RH20% to 80% RH
Storage Humidity Range10% to 90% RH10% to 90% RH
PricingCheck price on Amazon.Check price on Amazon.

HP 910 Yellow vs. HP 910XL High Yield Yellow

 HP 910 Yellow Original Ink Cartridge (3YL60AN)HP 910XL High Yield Yellow Original Ink Cartridge (3YL64AN)
Compatible PrintersHP OfficeJet 8010 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8020 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8022 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8025 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8028 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8035 All-in-One Printer
HP OfficeJet 8010 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8020 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8022 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8025 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8028 All-in-One Printer

HP OfficeJet 8035 All-in-One Printer
Ink TypePigmentPigment
Page YieldAround 315 pagesAround 825 pages
Operating Temperature Range59°F to 95°F59°F to 95°F
Storage Temperature Range-40°F to 140°F-40°F to 140°F
Operating Humidity Range20% to 80% RH20% to 80% RH
Storage Humidity Range10% to 90% RH10% to 90% RH
PricingCheck price on Amazon.Check price on Amazon.

HP 910 Compatible Printers

The HP 910 Black Original Cartridge, HP 910XL High Yield Black Original Cartridge, HP 910 Cyan Original Cartridge, HP 910XL High Yield Cyan Original Cartridge, HP 910 Magenta Original Cartridge, HP 910XL High Yield Magenta Original Cartridge, HP 910 Yellow Original Cartridge and HP 910XL High Yield Yellow Original Cartridge are compatible with the following printers:

  • HP OfficeJet 8010 All-in-One Printer
  • HP OfficeJet 8020 All-in-One Printer
  • HP OfficeJet 8022 All-in-One Printer
  • HP OfficeJet 8025 All-in-One Printer
  • HP OfficeJet 8028 All-in-One Printer
  • HP OfficeJet 8035 All-in-One Printer

Ink Type

The standard and XL versions of the HP 910 series use the pigment ink type for the black, cyan, magenta and yellow cartridges.

Page Yield

Page yield is a measurement that estimates how many pages can a full ink cartridge print out before it runs out of capacity and needs to be replaced.

When you compare the same colors, the HP 910XL High Yield Black Original can print approximately 525 more pages than the HP 910 Black Original. Thus, the XL version has a 175% advantage in this case.

The HP 910XL High Yield Cyan Original can produce around 510 more pages than the HP 910 Cyan Original.

Furthermore, the HP 910XL High Yield Magenta Original can also print out approximately 510 more pages than the HP 910XL High Yield Magenta Original.

Finally, the HP 910XL High Yield Yellow Original is capable of printing around 510 more pages than the HP 910 Yellow Original.

So, the XL versions of the cyan, magenta and yellow cartridges have a 161.91% yield advantage over the standard versions.

You can find the page yield specifications below:

  • HP 910 Black Original Ink Cartridge: Around 300 pages
  • HP 910XL High Yield Black Original Ink Cartridge: Around 825 pages
  • HP 910 Cyan Original Ink Cartridge: Around 315 pages
  • HP 910XL High Yield Cyan Original Ink Cartridge: Around 825 pages
  • HP 910 Magenta Original Ink Cartridge: Around 315 pages
  • HP 910XL High Yield Magenta Original Ink Cartridge: Around 825 pages
  • HP 910 Yellow Original Ink Cartridge: Around 315 pages
  • HP 910XL High Yield Yellow Original Ink Cartridge: Around 825 pages

All of the page yield tests were done internally by HP using the HP OfficeJet 8010 All-in-One Printer.

Operating Temperature Range

When it comes to the operating temperature range, the HP 910 Black, HP 910XL High Yield Black, HP 910 Cyan, HP 910XL High Yield Cyan, HP 910 Magenta, HP 910XL High Yield Magenta, HP 910 Yellow and HP 910XL High Yield Yellow all have to be operated from 59°F to 95°F.

Storage Temperature Range

The storage temperature ranges are identical for the HP910 series as you can store these products at -40°F to 140°F.

Operating Humidity Range

The standard and XL ink cartridges are also the same when it comes to the operating humidity range, which is from 20% to 80% RH.

Storage Humidity Range

Lastly, all color variants of the HP910 and HP910XL have identical storage humidity ranges at 10% to 90% RH.

Resources: