When you purchase through affiliate text and image links on Seeking Tech, we may earn a commission.

HP 58A vs. HP 58X

When purchasing the HP 58, you can pick between the A version and the X version. So, what are the main differences between these variants?

You can find out in this comparison guide.

Quick Summary

When compared to the HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge, the HP 58X High Yield Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge can print more than 3 times as many pages.

Therefore, we recommend picking up the X version over the A version of the HP 58. While the 58X costs more upfront, the high yield version will offer better value long term as it will last a lot longer than the 58A.

If you are interested, you can purchase either HP toner cartridges on Amazon with the following links:

HP 58A vs. HP 58X Comparison Chart

You can check out a comparison table between the two HP58 versions below.

 HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge (CF258A)HP 58X High Yield Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge (CF258X)
Compatible PrintersHP LaserJet Pro M404n (W1A52A#BGJ)

HP LaserJet Pro M404dn (W1A53A#BGJ)

HP LaserJet Pro M404dw (W1A56A#BGJ)

HP LaserJet Pro MFP M428fdn (W1A29A#BGJ)

HP LaserJet Pro MFP M428fdw (W1A30A#BGJ)
HP LaserJet Pro M404n (W1A52A#BGJ)

HP LaserJet Pro M404dn (W1A53A#BGJ)

HP LaserJet Pro M404dw (W1A56A#BGJ)

HP LaserJet Pro MFP M428fdn (W1A29A#BGJ)

HP LaserJet Pro MFP M428fdw (W1A30A#BGJ)
Print TechnologyLaserLaser
Page Yield3,000 pages10,000 pages
Operating Temperature Range50°F to 90.5°F50°F to 90.5°F
Storage Temperature Range-4°F to 104°F-4°F to 104°F
Operating Humidity Range20% to 80% RH20% to 80% RH
Storage Humidity Range10% to 90% RH10% to 90% RH
Package Dimensions14.25 in x 4.02 in x 7.80 in14.25 in x 4.02 in x 8.94 in
Package WeightAround 2.35 lbs.Around 2.97 lbs.
What's in the BoxTone Cartridge

Recycling Guide
Tone Cartridge

Recycling Guide
WarrantyHP's Premium Protection WarrantyHP's Premium Protection Warranty
PricingCheck price on Amazon.Check price on Amazon.

HP 58A and HP 58X Compatible Printers

The HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge and HP 58X High Yield Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge are compatible with the following printers:

  • HP LaserJet Pro M404n (W1A52A#BGJ)
  • HP LaserJet Pro M404dn (W1A53A#BGJ)
  • HP LaserJet Pro M404dw (W1A56A#BGJ)
  • HP LaserJet Pro MFP M428fdn (W1A29A#BGJ)
  • HP LaserJet Pro MFP M428fdw (W1A30A#BGJ)

Print Technology

The HP 58A Black and HP 58X High Yield Black both use the laser print technology.

Page Yield

Page yield measures the capacity of a HP toner cartridge in terms of how much paper it can print before having to be replaced with a new one.

According to internal tests done by HP using the ISO/IEC 19752 method, the HP 58X High Yield Black Original can print around 7,000 more pages when compared to the HP 58A Black Original.

As a result, the X variant of the HP58 has a 233.33% advantage over the A variant.

You can check out the page yield specs for the two products below:

  • HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge: 3,000 pages
  • HP 58X High Yield Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge: 10,000 pages

Operating Temperature Range

The HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge and HP 58X High Yield Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge have the same operating temperature range, which is from 50°F to 90.5°F.

Storage Temperature Range

The non-operating range for the HP 58 products is also identical with a range of -4°F to 104°F.

Operating Humidity Range

For operating humidity, the range needs to be at 20% to 80% RH for both the HP 58 A and HP 58 X.

Storage Humidity Range

Furthermore, you need a storage humidity range of 10% to 90% RH for these toner cartridges from HP.

Package Dimensions

When it comes to the packaging dimensions, the HP 58X is taller than the HP 58A. Otherwise, the two have the same length and depth.

You can take a look at the measurements for the two products below:

  • HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge: 14.25 in x 4.02 in x 7.80 in
  • HP 58X High Yield Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge: 14.25 in x 4.02 in x 8.94 in

Package Weight

The high yield version is also heavier when compared to the regular version.

You can check out the weight specifications below:

  • HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge: Around 2.35 lbs.
  • HP 58X High Yield Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge: Around 2.97 lbs.

What’s in the Box

Both HP 58 products come with a toner cartridge in addition to a recycling guide.

Warranty

The HP 58A and HP 58X also comes with HP’s Premium Protection Warranty, which guarantees that the cartridges will be free from defects.

Resources: