When you purchase through affiliate text and image links on Seeking Tech, we may earn a commission.

HP 920 vs. HP 920XL

When picking up the HP 920, you may have noticed that there are two variants as you can pick the normal version or XL version. So, what are the difference between these?

You can find out in this versus guide between the HP 920 and HP 920XL.

Quick Summary

The HP 920XL High Yield Black Original Ink Cartridge can print nearly 3 times as many pages than the HP 920 Black Original Ink Cartridge.

The HP 920XL High Yield Cyan Original Ink Cartridge, HP 920XL High Yield Magenta Original Ink Cartridge and HP 920XL High Yield Yellow Original Ink Cartridge can also print a little bit over twice as many pages as the HP 920 Cyan Original Ink Cartridge, HP 920 Magenta Original Ink Cartridge and HP 920 Yellow Original Ink Cartridge.

Therefore, we recommend getting the XL versions of the HP 920. Although these cartridges cost more upfront, they also provide better value over the long run due to much better page yield.

If you are interested, you can purchase any of the aforementioned products with the following links from Amazon:

Comparison Charts

You can take a look at the comparison tables for the HP920 and HP920XL below.

HP 920 Black vs. HP 920XL High Yield Black

 HP 920 Black Original Ink Cartridge (CD971AN)HP 920XL High Yield Black Original Ink Cartridge (CD975AN)
Compatible PrintersHP Officejet 6000A

HP Officejet 6500

HP Officejet 6500A

HP Officejet 7000

HP Officejet 7500

HP Officejet 7500A
HP Officejet 6000A

HP Officejet 6500

HP Officejet 6500A

HP Officejet 7000

HP Officejet 7500

HP Officejet 7500A
Ink TypePigmentPigment
Ink Drop14 pl HDW14 pl HDW
Page YieldsAround 420 pagesAround 1200 pages
Operating Temperature Range41°F to 104°F41°F to 104°F
Storage Temperature Range-40°F to 158°F-40°F to 158°F
Operating Humidity Range5% to 80% RH5% to 80% RH
Storage Humidity Range5% to 80% RH5% to 80% RH
PricingCheck price on Amazon.Check price on Amazon.

HP 920 Cyan vs. HP 920XL High Yield Cyan

 HP 920 Cyan Original Ink Cartridge (CH634AN)HP 920XL High Yield Cyan Original Ink Cartridge (CD972AN)
Compatible PrintersHP Officejet 6000A

HP Officejet 6500

HP Officejet 6500A

HP Officejet 7000

HP Officejet 7500

HP Officejet 7500A
HP Officejet 6000A

HP Officejet 6500

HP Officejet 6500A

HP Officejet 7000

HP Officejet 7500

HP Officejet 7500A
Ink TypeDyeDye
Ink Drop5.5 pl HDW, 1.3 pl LDW5.5 pl HDW, 1.3 pl LDW
Page YieldsAround 300 pagesAround 700 pages
Operating Temperature Range41°F to 104°F41°F to 104°F
Storage Temperature Range-40°F to 158°F-40°F to 158°F
Operating Humidity Range5% to 80% RH5% to 80% RH
Storage Humidity Range5% to 80% RH5% to 80% RH
PricingCheck price on Amazon.Check price on Amazon.

HP 920 Magenta vs. HP 920XL High Yield Magenta

 HP 920 Magenta Original Ink Cartridge (CH635AN)HP 920XL High Yield Magenta Original Ink Cartridge (CD973AN)
Compatible PrintersHP Officejet 6000A

HP Officejet 6500

HP Officejet 6500A

HP Officejet 7000

HP Officejet 7500

HP Officejet 7500A
HP Officejet 6000A

HP Officejet 6500

HP Officejet 6500A

HP Officejet 7000

HP Officejet 7500

HP Officejet 7500A
Ink TypeDyeDye
Ink Drop5.5 pl HDW, 1.3 pl LDW5.5 pl HDW, 1.3 pl LDW
Page YieldsAround 300 pagesAround 700 pages
Operating Temperature Range41°F to 104°F41°F to 104°F
Storage Temperature Range-40°F to 158°F-40°F to 158°F
Operating Humidity Range5% to 80% RH5% to 80% RH
Storage Humidity Range5% to 80% RH5% to 80% RH
PricingCheck price on Amazon.Check price on Amazon.

HP 920 Yellow vs. HP 920XL High Yield Yellow

 HP 920 Yellow Original Ink Cartridge (CH636AN)HP 920XL High Yield Yellow Original Ink Cartridge (CD974AN)
Compatible PrintersHP Officejet 6000A

HP Officejet 6500

HP Officejet 6500A

HP Officejet 7000

HP Officejet 7500

HP Officejet 7500A
HP Officejet 6000A

HP Officejet 6500

HP Officejet 6500A

HP Officejet 7000

HP Officejet 7500

HP Officejet 7500A
Ink TypeDyeDye
Ink Drop5.5 pl HDW, 1.3 pl LDW5.5 pl HDW, 1.3 pl LDW
Page YieldsAround 300 pagesAround 700 pages
Operating Temperature Range41°F to 104°F41°F to 104°F
Storage Temperature Range-40°F to 158°F-40°F to 158°F
Operating Humidity Range5% to 80% RH5% to 80% RH
Storage Humidity Range5% to 80% RH5% to 80% RH
PricingCheck price on Amazon.Check price on Amazon.

HP 920 and HP 920XL Compatible Printers

The HP 920 Black Original, HP 920XL High Yield Black Original, HP 920 Cyan Original, HP 920XL High Yield Cyan Original, HP 920 Magenta Original, HP 920XL High Yield Magenta Original, HP 920 Yellow Original and HP 920XL High Yield Yellow Original Cartridges support the following printers:

  • HP Officejet 6000A
  • HP Officejet 6500
  • HP Officejet 6500A
  • HP Officejet 7000
  • HP Officejet 7500
  • HP Officejet 7500A

Ink Type

The black color cartridges of the HP920 and HP 920XL use the pigment ink type.

The cyan, magenta and yellow cartridges of the HP920 and HP 920XL utilize the dye ink type.

Ink Drop

When you compare the same colors, the HP920 and HP920XL have the same ink drop specifications.

You can find the specs below:

  • HP 920 Black: 14 pl HDW
  • HP 920XL High Yield Black: 14 pl HDW
  • HP 920 Cyan: 5.5 pl HDW, 1.3 pl LDW
  • HP 920XL High Yield Cyan: 5.5 pl HDW, 1.3 pl LDW
  • HP 920 Magenta: 5.5 pl HDW, 1.3 pl LDW
  • HP 920XL High Yield Magenta: 5.5 pl HDW, 1.3 pl LDW
  • HP 920 Yellow: 5.5 pl HDW, 1.3 pl LDW
  • HP 920XL High Yield Yellow: 5.5 pl HDW, 1.3 pl LDW

Page Yields

When it comes to page yields, the HP 920XL High Yield Black can print around 780 more pages than the HP 920 Black. This translates to a 185.71% advantage.

The HP 920XL High Yield Cyan, HP 920XL High Yield Magenta and HP 920XL High Yield Yellow are also able to print out approximately 400 more pages when compared to the HP 920 Cyan, HP 920 Magenta and HP 920 Yellow.

Thus, the XL versions of the cyan, magenta and yellow ink cartridges have a 133.33% advantage.

The page yields were tested by HP using the aforementioned HP Officejet 6500 All-in-One Printer.

You can find the test results below:

  • HP 920 Black: Around 420 pages
  • HP 920XL High Yield Black: Around 1200 pages
  • HP 920 Cyan: Around 300 pages
  • HP 920XL High Yield Cyan: Around 700 pages
  • HP 920 Magenta: Around 300 pages
  • HP 920XL High Yield Magenta: Around 700 pages
  • HP 920 Yellow: Around 300 pages
  • HP 920XL High Yield Yellow: Around 700 pages

Operating Temperature Range

The HP 920 Black, HP 920XL High Yield Black, HP 920 Cyan, HP 920XL High Yield Cyan, HP 920 Magenta, HP 920XL High Yield Magenta, HP 920 Yellow and HP 920XL High Yield Yellow require an operating temperature range of 41°F to 104°F.

Storage Temperature Range

For non-operating use, you need to store these ink cartridges within a range of -40°F to 158°F.

Operating Humidity Range

For humidity, these products need to be at 5% to 80% RH during operation.

Storage Humidity Range

You also need to store these cartridges at 5% to 80% RH.

Resources: