When you purchase through affiliate text and image links on Seeking Tech, we may earn a commission.

HP 74 vs. HP 74XL and HP 75 vs. HP 75XL

HP has two versions of the 74 and 75 original ink cartridges. So, what are the differences between the regular and high yield editions?

You can find out in this comparison guide for these printer cartridge replacements.

Quick Summary

With the HP 74XL High Yield Black Original Ink Cartridge, you can print 275% more paper than the HP 74 Black Original Ink Cartridge.

With the HP 75XL High Yield Tri-color Original Ink Cartridge, you can print 205.88% more paper than the HP 75 Tri-color Original Ink Cartridge.

So, while the high yield versions are more costly upfront, you will get more value as these cartridges are able to print a lot more paper when compared to the regular versions.

You can buy any of the aforementioned ink cartridges, if you are interested, on Amazon with the following links:

HP 74 vs. HP 74XL and HP 75 vs. HP 75XL Comparison Charts

You can check out the comparison tables for the HP 74 and HP 75 ink cartridges below.

HP 74 Black vs. HP 74XL High Yield Black

 HP 74 Black Original Ink Cartridge (CB335WN)HP 74XL High Yield Black Original Ink Cartridge (CB336WN)
Compatible PrintersHP Deskjet D4260

HP Deskjet D4360

HP Officejet J5780

HP Officejet J5788

HP Officejet J6480

HP Photosmart C4280

HP Photosmart C4342

HP Photosmart C4344

HP Photosmart C4382

HP Photosmart C4384

HP Photosmart C4385

HP Photosmart C4435

HP Photosmart C4440

HP Photosmart C4480

HP Photosmart C4524

HP Photosmart C4540

HP Photosmart C4550

HP Photosmart C4580

HP Photosmart C4599

HP Photosmart C5280

HP Photosmart C5540

HP Photosmart C5550

HP Photosmart C5580

HP Photosmart D5360
HP Deskjet D4260

HP Deskjet D4360

HP Officejet J5780

HP Officejet J5788

HP Officejet J6480

HP Photosmart C4280

HP Photosmart C4342

HP Photosmart C4344

HP Photosmart C4382

HP Photosmart C4384

HP Photosmart C4385

HP Photosmart C4435

HP Photosmart C4440

HP Photosmart C4480

HP Photosmart C4524

HP Photosmart C4540

HP Photosmart C4550

HP Photosmart C4580

HP Photosmart C4599

HP Photosmart C5280

HP Photosmart C5540

HP Photosmart C5550

HP Photosmart C5580

HP Photosmart D5360
Package Dimensions4.49 x 1.43 x 4.05 in4.49 x 1.43 x 4.05 in
Package WeightAround 0.10 lb.Around 0.14 lb.
Ink TypePigmentPigment
Ink Drop15 pl15 pl
Page YieldAround 200 pagesAround 750 pages
Operating Temperature Range59°F to 86°F59°F to 86°F
Storage Temperature Range59°F to 95°F59°F to 95°F
Operating Humidity Range20% to 80% RH20% to 80% RH
Storage Humidity Range5% to 95% RH5% to 95% RH
PricingCheck price on Amazon.Check price on Amazon.

HP 75 Tri-color vs. HP 75XL High Yield Tri-color

 HP 75 Tri-color Original Ink Cartridge (CB337WN)HP 75XL High Yield Tri-color Original Ink Cartridge (CB338WN)
Compatible PrintersHP Deskjet D4260

HP Deskjet D4360

HP Officejet J5780

HP Officejet J5788

HP Officejet J6480

HP Photosmart C4280

HP Photosmart C4342

HP Photosmart C4344

HP Photosmart C4382

HP Photosmart C4384

HP Photosmart C4385

HP Photosmart C4435

HP Photosmart C4440

HP Photosmart C4480

HP Photosmart C4524

HP Photosmart C4540

HP Photosmart C4550

HP Photosmart C4580

HP Photosmart C4599

HP Photosmart C5280

HP Photosmart C5540

HP Photosmart C5550

HP Photosmart C5580

HP Photosmart D5360
HP Deskjet D4260

HP Deskjet D4360

HP Officejet J5780

HP Officejet J5788

HP Officejet J6480

HP Photosmart C4280

HP Photosmart C4342

HP Photosmart C4344

HP Photosmart C4382

HP Photosmart C4384

HP Photosmart C4385

HP Photosmart C4435

HP Photosmart C4440

HP Photosmart C4480

HP Photosmart C4524

HP Photosmart C4540

HP Photosmart C4550

HP Photosmart C4580

HP Photosmart C4599

HP Photosmart C5280

HP Photosmart C5540

HP Photosmart C5550

HP Photosmart C5580

HP Photosmart D5360
Package Dimensions4.49 x 1.43 x 4.05 in4.49 x 1.43 x 4.05 in
Package WeightAround 0.11 lb.Around 0.13 lb.
Ink TypeDyeDye
Ink Drop5 pl5 pl
Page YieldAround 170 pagesAround 520 pages
Operating Temperature Range59°F to 86°F59°F to 86°F
Storage Temperature Range59°F to 95°F59°F to 95°F
Operating Humidity Range20% to 80% RH20% to 80% RH
Storage Humidity Range5% to 95% RH5% to 95% RH
PricingCheck price on Amazon.Check price on Amazon.

HP 74 and HP 75 Compatible Printers

HP 74 Black, HP 74XL High Yield Black, HP 75 Tri-color and HP 75XL High Yield Tri-color can be used with the following printers:

  • HP Deskjet D4260
  • HP Deskjet D4360
  • HP Officejet J5780
  • HP Officejet J5788
  • HP Officejet J6480
  • HP Photosmart C4280
  • HP Photosmart C4342
  • HP Photosmart C4344
  • HP Photosmart C4382
  • HP Photosmart C4384
  • HP Photosmart C4385
  • HP Photosmart C4435
  • HP Photosmart C4440
  • HP Photosmart C4480
  • HP Photosmart C4524
  • HP Photosmart C4540
  • HP Photosmart C4550
  • HP Photosmart C4580
  • HP Photosmart C4599
  • HP Photosmart C5280
  • HP Photosmart C5540
  • HP Photosmart C5550
  • HP Photosmart C5580
  • HP Photosmart D5360

Package Dimensions

The packages for the HP74 and HP75 cartridges are identical in size.

You can find the measurements for these packages (which is displayed as Width x Depth x Height) below:

  • 4.49 x 1.43 x 4.05 in

Package Weight

  • HP 74 Black: Around 0.10 lb.
  • HP 74XL High Yield Black: Around 0.14 lb.
  • HP 75 Tri-color: Around 0.11 lb.
  • HP 75XL High Yield Tri-color: Around 0.13 lb.

Ink Type

The regular and high yield versions of the HP 74 Black use the same pigment ink type.

Moreover, the regular and high yield versions of the HP 75 Tri-color use the same dye ink type.

Ink Drop

The two variants of the HP 74 Black have an ink drop of 15 pl.

Furthermore, the two versions of the HP 75 Tri-color have an ink drop of 5 pl.

Page Yield

When it comes to page yields, you will get much better results with the XL version that the regular versions.

According to internal tests done by HP using the Officejet J5780 All-in-One Printer series, you can print approximately 550 more pages with the HP 74XL High Yield Black Cartridge than the HP 74 Black Cartridge. This is an increase of 275%.

The HP 75XL High Yield Tri-color Cartridge can also print 350 more pages than the HP 75 Tri-color Cartridge. This translates to an increase of 205.88%.

You can take a look at the page yield specifications below:

  • HP 74 Black: Around 200 pages
  • HP 74XL High Yield Black: Around 750 pages
  • HP 75 Tri-color: Around 170 pages
  • HP 75XL High Yield Tri-color: Around 520 pages

Operating Temperature Range

The HP 74 Black, HP 74XL High Yield Black, HP 75 Tri-color and HP 75XL High Yield Tri-color has the same operating temperature range at 59°F to 86°F.

Storage Temperature Range

The HP74 and HP75 cartridges are also identical when it comes to storage temperature range, which is from 59°F to 95°F.

Operating Humidity Range

Furthermore, the products have the same operating humidity range of 20% to 80% RH.

Storage Humidity Range

Last but not least, the ink cartridges are also identical when it comes to storage humidity range 5% to 95% RH

Resources: