When you purchase through affiliate text and image links on Seeking Tech, we may earn a commission.

BarraCuda 510 vs. BarraCuda Q5

Seagate recently released the BarraCuda Q5 Solid State Drive. So, how does the new storage drive stack up against the similar BarraCuda 510? You can find out in this comparison guide between the two M.2 NVMe SSDs.

Quick Summary

When compared to the Seagate BarraCuda Q5, the Seagate BarraCuda 510 has much faster maximum sequential read speed and maximum sequential write speed.

The BarraCuda 510 also has a significant advantage at endurance and features a longer warranty coverage length.

From a power usage standpoint, the BarraCuda Q5 consumes less while active and in a low powered state while the BarraCuda 510 consumes less while idle.

The only other advantage the Q5 model has over the 510 model is that the Q5 is the only one of the two to offer a 2 TB option.

So, if you want the fastest speeds and best endurance, then we recommend getting the BarraCuda 510.

If you want a 2TB M.2 NVMe solid state drive, then the BarraCuda Q5 is the only option out of these two products.

If you are interested, you can purchase either of the two storage drives on Amazon with the following links:

BarraCuda 510 vs. BarraCuda Q5 Comparison Chart

You can check out the comparison table for the two Seagate SSDs below.

 Seagate BarraCuda 510 SSDSeagate BarraCuda Q5 SSD
Capacity Options250GB: ZP250CM30001

256GB: ZP256CM30031

500GB: ZP500CM30001

512GB: ZP512CM30031

1TB: ZP1000CM30001
500GB: ZP500CV30001

1TB: ZP1000CV30001

2TB: ZP2000CV30001
InterfacesNVMe1.3

PCIe Gen3 ×4
NVMe1.3

PCIe Gen3 ×4
NAND Flash Memory3D TLC3D QLC
Form FactorM.2 2280M.2 2280
Dimensions80.15 mm x 22.15 mm x 2.23 mm or 3.156 in x 0.872 in x 0.087 in80.00 mm x 22.00 mm x 2.15 mm or 3.149 in x 0.866 in x 0.084 in
General FeaturesHalogen Free

RoHS Compliant

S.M.A.R.T.

TRIM
Halogen Free

RoHS Compliant

S.M.A.R.T.

TRIM
Maximum Sequential Read Speed250GB BarraCuda 510: Up to 3100 MB per second

256GB BarraCuda 510: Up to 3100 MB per second

500GB BarraCuda 510: Up to 3400 MB per second

512GB BarraCuda 510: Up to 3400 MB per second

1TB BarraCuda 510: Up to 3400 MB per second
500GB BarraCuda Q5: Up to 2400 MB per second

1TB BarraCuda Q5: Up to 2400 MB per second

2TB BarraCuda Q5: Up to 2300 MB per second
Maximum Sequential Write Speed250GB BarraCuda 510: Up to 1200 MB per second

256GB BarraCuda 510: Up to 1050 MB per second

500GB BarraCuda 510: Up to 2400 MB per second

512GB BarraCuda 510: Up to 2180 MB per second

1TB BarraCuda 510: Up to 3000 MB per second
500GB BarraCuda Q5: Up to 900 MB per second

1TB BarraCuda Q5: Up to 1700 MB per second

2TB BarraCuda Q5: Up to 1800 MB per second
Average Active Power250GB BarraCuda 510: 3.0 W

256GB BarraCuda 510: 3.0 W

500GB BarraCuda 510: 4.6 W

512GB BarraCuda 510: 4.2 W

1TB BarraCuda 510: 5.3 W
500GB BarraCuda Q5: 2.2 W

1TB BarraCuda Q5: 3.1 W

2TB BarraCuda Q5: 3.3 W
Average Idle Power PS3250GB BarraCuda 510: 16 mW

256GB BarraCuda 510: 16 mW

500GB BarraCuda 510: 16 mW

512GB BarraCuda 510: 16 mW

1TB BarraCuda 510: 20 mW
500GB BarraCuda Q5: 23 mW

1TB BarraCuda Q5: 27 mW

2TB BarraCuda Q5: 25 mW
Low Power L1.2 Mode250GB BarraCuda 510: 2 mW

256GB BarraCuda 510: 2 mW

500GB BarraCuda 510: 2 mW

512GB BarraCuda 510: 2 mW

1TB BarraCuda 510: 2 mW
500GB BarraCuda Q5: 1.5 mW

1TB BarraCuda Q5: 1.6 mW

2TB BarraCuda Q5: 1.6 mW
Endurance250GB BarraCuda 510: 160 TBW

256GB BarraCuda 510: 160 TBW

500GB BarraCuda 510: 320 TBW

512GB BarraCuda 510: 320 TBW

1TB BarraCuda 510: 640 TBW
500GB BarraCuda Q5: 119 TBW

1TB BarraCuda Q5: 274 TBW

2TB BarraCuda Q5: 531 TBW
Reliability1,800,000 hours1,800,000 hours
Operating Temperature0°C to 70°C0°C to 70°C
Non-Operating Temperature–40°C to 85°C–40°C to 85°C
Non-Operating Shock Resistance1500 G at 0.5ms1500 G at 0.5ms
Warranty5-year limited warranty3-year limited warranty
PricingCheck price on Amazon.Check price on Amazon.

Capacity Options

You have five capacity options available for the BarraCuda 510 as you can pick between 250 GB, 256 GB, 500 GB, 512 GB and 1 TB. The BarraCuda Q5 is available in three capacities: 500 GB, 1 TB and 2 TB. You can find the model number for each option below:

Seagate BarraCuda 510:

  • 250GB: ZP250CM30001
  • 256GB: ZP256CM30031
  • 500GB: ZP500CM30001
  • 512GB: ZP512CM30031
  • 1TB: ZP1000CM30001

Seagate BarraCuda Q5:

  • 500GB: ZP500CV30001
  • 1TB: ZP1000CV30001
  • 2TB: ZP2000CV30001

Interfaces

The BarraCuda 510 and BarraCuda Q5 use the same NVMe1.3 and PCIe Gen3 ×4 interfaces.

NAND Flash Memory

For NAND, the Seagate BarraCuda 510 is equipped with 3D TLC while the Seagate BarraCuda Q5 is equipped with 3D QLC.

Form Factor

The two internal storage drives in this versus guide utilize the same M.2 2280 form factor.

Dimensions

The BarraCuda 510 is slightly bigger when compared to the BarraCuda Q5. You can take a look at the measurements below:

  • BarraCuda 510: 80.15 mm x 22.15 mm x 2.23 mm or 3.156 in x 0.872 in x 0.087 in
  • BarraCuda Q5: 80.00 mm x 22.00 mm x 2.15 mm or 3.149 in x 0.866 in x 0.084 in

General Features

The Seagate BarraCuda 510 and Q5 Solid State Drives share the same general features, which you can find below:

  • Halogen Free
  • RoHS Compliant
  • S.M.A.R.T.
  • TRIM

Maximum Sequential Read Speed

In general, the BarraCuda 510 is much faster than the BarraCuda Q5 at maximum sequential reading speed. When you compared the same capacity options, the 500 GB and 1 TB versions of the BarraCuda 510 SSD is 1000 MB per second faster (or 41.67% faster) than the 500 GB and 1 TB versions of the BarraCuda Q5 SSD.

You can take a look at max sequential read speed specifications below:

  • 250GB BarraCuda 510: Up to 3100 MB per second
  • 256GB BarraCuda 510: Up to 3100 MB per second
  • 500GB BarraCuda 510: Up to 3400 MB per second
  • 512GB BarraCuda 510: Up to 3400 MB per second
  • 1TB BarraCuda 510: Up to 3400 MB per second
  • 500GB BarraCuda Q5: Up to 2400 MB per second
  • 1TB BarraCuda Q5: Up to 2400 MB per second
  • 2TB BarraCuda Q5: Up to 2300 MB per second

Maximum Sequential Write Speed

When it comes to the maximum sequential writing, the Seagate BarraCuda 510 also has a big advantage over the Seagate BarraCuda Q5. The 500 GB BarraCuda 510 is 1500 MB per second faster (or 166.67% faster) than the 500 GB BarraCuda Q5 while the 1 TB BarraCuda 510 is 1300 MB per second faster (or 76.47% faster) than the 1 TB BarraCuda Q5.

You can check out the max sequential write speed specs below:

  • 250GB BarraCuda 510: Up to 1200 MB per second
  • 256GB BarraCuda 510: Up to 1050 MB per second
  • 500GB BarraCuda 510: Up to 2400 MB per second
  • 512GB BarraCuda 510: Up to 2180 MB per second
  • 1TB BarraCuda 510: Up to 3000 MB per second
  • 500GB BarraCuda Q5: Up to 900 MB per second
  • 1TB BarraCuda Q5: Up to 1700 MB per second
  • 2TB BarraCuda Q5: Up to 1800 MB per second

Average Active Power

The BarraCuda Q5 does consume less energy while active when compared to the BarraCuda 510. You can check out the average active power statistics below:

  • 250GB BarraCuda 510: 3.0 W
  • 256GB BarraCuda 510: 3.0 W
  • 500GB BarraCuda 510: 4.6 W
  • 512GB BarraCuda 510: 4.2 W
  • 1TB BarraCuda 510: 5.3 W
  • 500GB BarraCuda Q5: 2.2 W
  • 1TB BarraCuda Q5: 3.1 W
  • 2TB BarraCuda Q5: 3.3 W

Average Idle Power PS3

On the other hand, the 510 model has lower average idle power consumption than the Q5 model. You can find the idle power stats below:

  • 250GB BarraCuda 510: 16 mW
  • 256GB BarraCuda 510: 16 mW
  • 500GB BarraCuda 510: 16 mW
  • 512GB BarraCuda 510: 16 mW
  • 1TB BarraCuda 510: 20 mW
  • 500GB BarraCuda Q5: 23 mW
  • 1TB BarraCuda Q5: 27 mW
  • 2TB BarraCuda Q5: 25 mW

Low Power L1.2 Mode

The Q5 consumes less in low power mode when compared to the 510. You can find the low power consumption specs below:

  • 250GB BarraCuda 510: 2 mW
  • 256GB BarraCuda 510: 2 mW
  • 500GB BarraCuda 510: 2 mW
  • 512GB BarraCuda 510: 2 mW
  • 1TB BarraCuda 510: 2 mW
  • 500GB BarraCuda Q5: 1.5 mW
  • 1TB BarraCuda Q5: 1.6 mW
  • 2TB BarraCuda Q5: 1.6 mW

Endurance

In general, the Seagate BarraCuda 510 Solid State Drive has better endurance than the Seagate BarraCuda Q5. When comparing the same capacities, you can write 201 TB more data (or 168.91% more data) with the 500GB 510 SSD than the 500GB Q5 SSD as well as 366 TB more data (or 133.58% more data) with the 1TB 510 SSD than the 1TB Q5 SSD.

You can check out the endurance specifications, in terms of Terabytes Written (TBW), below:

  • 250GB BarraCuda 510: 160 TBW
  • 256GB BarraCuda 510: 160 TBW
  • 500GB BarraCuda 510: 320 TBW
  • 512GB BarraCuda 510: 320 TBW
  • 1TB BarraCuda 510: 640 TBW
  • 500GB BarraCuda Q5: 119 TBW
  • 1TB BarraCuda Q5: 274 TBW
  • 2TB BarraCuda Q5: 531 TBW

Reliability

Reliability for both the Seagate BarraCuda 510 and Q5 is measured as Mean Time Between Failures (MTBF). This specification stands for the estimated amount of time a solid state drive should remain functional in between two critical hardware failures. The two devices have a MTBF of 1,800,000 hours each.

Operating Temperature

The M.2 NVMe SSDs have the same operating temperature range of 0°C to 70°C.

Non-Operating Temperature

The BarraCuda 510 and Q5 also have the same non-operating temperature range of –40°C to 85°C.

Non-Operating Shock Resistance

Furthermore, the two internal storage drives have the same non-operating shock resistance, which is 1500 G at 0.5ms.

Warranty

The Seagate BarraCuda 510 SSD comes with a 5-year limited warranty while the Seagate BarraCuda Q5 SSD comes with a 3-year limited warranty.

Resources: